Smackety Smack

I’ve been continuing to think about discipline the past few weeks.  I feel like we’re coming to a threshold where catering to Ruby’s every whim will no longer be the best parenting philosophy.  Not sure when, and it’ll probably be a gradual change, but it’s coming…

I read T. Berry Brazelton’s Discipline: The Brazelton Way last week and it didn’t provide much insight.  It’s a pretty short book, and so it moves pretty quickly, glossing over important areas and not really explaining the underlying psychology in detail.  The best parts of the book, and they are rare, are the dialogues between parent and child that illlustrate good and bad parenting techniques.  If I could find a large collection of those, that would be useful.

Down in New Zealand, a Christian group is promoting a more old-school approach to discipline:

Family Integrity has produced a controversial eight-page booklet on how to use physical punishment under the present law.

Parents are told that smacking can be a “10-to-15-minute process” and that if a child reacts angrily, such as by slamming doors or “pouting”, they should be smacked again.

“Smacking is meant to drive the foolishness, the sinful manifestations, out of the child’s personality so that they do not become permanent fixtures,” it says.

My favorite quote from the pro-smacking booklet:

“If the child is angry after the smack, you have not smacked hard enough.”


Kate has a few comments about the current state of discipline over at Ruby’s Blog.


Tags: , ,

3 Responses to “Smackety Smack”

  1. My Name Is Ruby » Not Every Whim… Says:

    […] Unlike Steve, I have already been trying out some discipline with Ruby. She’s developed an unpleasant habit during nursing where she writhes and turns away. Not only is it annoying and time-consuming, it leads to sore nipples for me. At best, she squirms a bit during feedings. At worst, she arches her back and cries as well. Weirdly, she always turns her head away to the right. I don’t know why. […]

  2. Lorraine White Says:

    I can’t BELIEVE what I just read! Not only advocating “swatting” or spanking but outright SMACKING of a child! It’s obvious you know NOTHING about child behavior! I raised a wonderful, respectful, obedient child without EVER hitting him! (He’s 16 now!). If you don’t care about the VIOLENCE you’re teaching your child by hitting, maybe you care that in almost every state, what you’re doing is CRIMINAL! Yes, and usually a felony. SHAME On you! You’ll live to regret this when your kid starts beating up others and eventually ends up in therapy or jail, blaming YOU (rightly so!).

  3. steve Says:

    It should be noted that Lorraine White, above, is a complete stranger and knows nothing about myself, Kate, or Ruby. If she did, then she’d understand that of course this post describes pretty much the exact opposite of our parenting style.

    No, shame on YOU.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: